
Hawthorne Hotel
Best for history-focused stays, events and weddings in Salem and travelers who want easy walking access to Salem’s main sights.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hawthorne Hotel is a historic 1925 hotel in downtown Salem, ideal for travelers who want immediate access to Salem Common, witch-trial sites, and a classic New England stay. The Newbury Boston is a five-star luxury hotel on Newbury Street across from the Boston Public Garden, best for travelers who want a central, upscale base for shopping, museums, and Boston city attractions.
Updated

Best for history-focused stays, events and weddings in Salem and travelers who want easy walking access to Salem’s main sights.

Best for a luxury city stay on Newbury Street with easy access to Boston Public Garden, museums, shopping, and meeting/event space.
When Hawthorne Hotel wins: Choose Hawthorne if you want a smaller, characterful hotel steps from Salem Common and historic attractions, if you need free self-parking, or if you prefer a property with on-site classic dining and frequent wedding/event offerings.
When The Newbury Boston wins: Choose The Newbury Boston if you want a full-service, five-star experience in central Boston with extensive accessibility features, designer bedding, more room types and suites, meeting rooms, valet parking, and an on-site bar/restaurant with 24-hour room service.
Bottom line: Pick Hawthorne for a compact, historic Salem base and lower-key on-site dining and parking; pick The Newbury Boston for a larger, luxury downtown Boston stay with more room variety, on-site services, and a high guest rating.
| Category | Hawthorne Hotel | The Newbury Boston |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, traditional New England hotel with period details | Contemporary luxury hotel on Newbury Street with designer finishes |
| Location | 18 Washington Square W, beside Salem Common; walking distance to Salem Witch Museum and PEM | One Newbury Street, steps from Boston Public Garden and Newbury Street shops |
| Size (rooms) | 93 guest rooms and suites | 286 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family- and pet-friendly (pet rooms on 6th floor) | Family-friendly; not adults-only |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | |
| Restaurants & bars | Nathaniel's (breakfast, dinner) and The Tavern (pub fare, bar with fireplace) | The Street Bar (bar/lounge), 24-hour room service; on-site restaurant (1) |
| Spa & fitness | Small fitness room; a spa room is noted but no named full-service spa | 24-hour fitness facilities; health/beauty spa services referenced as nearby |
| Known for | Historic setting, event and wedding venues (Grand Ballroom, Sophia's), Salem location | Luxury accommodations, Newbury Street location, designer bedding and amenities |
| Meeting & event space | Over 8,000 sq ft (Grand Ballroom, multiple meeting rooms) for weddings and events | 6 meeting rooms available for events |
| Parking | Free self-serve parking in two lots behind property (first-come, first-served) | Garage and covered/secured parking; valet parking (surcharge) |
| Smoke-free | Smoke-free property | |
Hawthorne Hotel sits beside Salem Common and is within easy walking distance of the Salem Witch Museum and Peabody Essex Museum.
Choose Hawthorne if you want to be in the historical heart of Salem and walk to most attractions.
The Newbury Boston is on Newbury Street, a short walk to Boston Public Garden and Copley Square.
Choose The Newbury Boston for immediate access to Boston’s core attractions and Newbury Street shopping.
Hawthorne Hotel is small and historic, with 93 rooms (including six suites) that emphasize period charm.
Choose Hawthorne for historic rooms and a compact inventory—good if you want a smaller hotel experience in Salem.
The Newbury Boston offers many room types and suite configurations with luxury bedding and in-room amenities.
Choose The Newbury Boston if you want more room variety, upscale linens, and accessible room options.
Hawthorne Hotel has two on-site venues serving breakfast, lunch and dinner in period settings.
Hawthorne is a good pick for straightforward, on-site dining with historic atmosphere and a lively pub.
The Newbury Boston provides a single bar/lounge (The Street Bar) and 24-hour room service; cooked breakfasts are available for a fee.
Choose The Newbury Boston if you want upscale in-room dining options and a central hotel bar near high-end shopping and attractions.
Hawthorne Hotel does not have an on-site swimming pool but provides event spaces and local access to beaches and waterfront activities.
Hawthorne’s signature amenity is its historic event space and prime Salem location rather than a pool.
The Newbury Boston’s appeal is its downtown luxury services and proximity to Boston attractions rather than poolside facilities.
The Newbury’s signature is downtown luxury and service rather than recreational pool facilities.
Hawthorne offers a small fitness room and on-site evening dining with live music on certain nights.
Hawthorne works for light fitness needs and evening pub-style nights in a historic setting.
The Newbury Boston provides a 24-hour fitness center and a full set of accessibility features; nightlife centers on nearby Boston venues and in-hotel bar service.
The Newbury is the stronger choice for fitness, accessibility, and walking access to Boston nightlife.

Hawthorne Hotel — true historic property steps from Salem Common and the city’s main attractions.

The Newbury Boston — five-star hotel on Newbury Street, ideal for shopping and museum access.

Hawthorne Hotel — large Grand Ballroom and multiple historic event rooms for wedding and conference gatherings.

The Newbury Boston — many accessible room types, roll-in showers, and a wide range of suites and views.
The Newbury Boston — it’s in central Boston near the Public Garden, museums, theatres and Newbury Street shopping.
Hawthorne Hotel — it sits beside Salem Common and is an easy walk to Salem’s main historic attractions and tour starting points.
No — neither hotel lists an on-site swimming pool.
Yes — both properties welcome families. Hawthorne explicitly offers pet-friendly rooms and kid-friendly dining options; The Newbury is family-friendly and not adults-only.
Explore how Hawthorne Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·