
Hawthorne Hotel
Best for history, classic New England character, and on-site event or wedding spaces near Salem Common.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hawthorne Hotel is a historic, 93-room hotel beside Salem Common with on-site restaurants and event space — good for history-minded travelers, families, and wedding groups. Salem Waterfront Hotel & Suites is an upper-midscale, 87-room waterfront property near Pickering Wharf with a marina and indoor pool — good for travelers who want harbor access and convention/event facilities.
Updated · about 0.3 km apart

Best for history, classic New England character, and on-site event or wedding spaces near Salem Common.

Best for travelers who want harbor views, a marina/walkway-to-water and an indoor pool within easy walking distance of central Salem attractions.
When Hawthorne Hotel wins: choose Hawthorne if you want a historic property steps from Salem Common and museums, hotel-run restaurants with local character, or if you need traditional event/wedding spaces in the heart of downtown.
When Salem Waterfront Hotel & Suites wins: choose Salem Waterfront if you prefer staying right on the water, want an indoor pool and marina access, or need mid-sized conference space with a central Pickering Wharf/harbor location.
Bottom line: Hawthorne is the downtown, historic choice for atmosphere and weddings; Salem Waterfront is the practical waterfront alternative with pool and marina facilities. Either is walkable to Salem’s main attractions, so pick based on whether waterfront views/pool or historic‑downtown ambiance matter more.
| Category | Hawthorne Hotel | Salem Waterfront Hotel & Suites |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, downtown hotel beside Salem Common with traditional public rooms. | Upper-midscale waterfront hotel focused on harbor access and conference space. |
| Location | 18 Washington Square W — adjacent to Salem Common and close to museums. | 225 Derby St — on the harbor with a marina and walkway-to-water. |
| Size | 93 guestrooms (including 6 suites). | 87 guestrooms. |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; primary booker must be 21+. | All ages welcome (adultsOnly: false). |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool. | Indoor pool on property. |
| Restaurants & bars | Nathaniel's (breakfast/dinner) and The Tavern (pub, bar, fireside seating). | Mainstay Social (restaurant with bar/lounge) plus room service during limited hours. |
| Spa / wellness | Small on-site spa room mentioned (limited services) and a tiny fitness room; complimentary access to nearby fitness centers reported. | Not published |
| Event / meeting space | Large historic event inventory — Grand Ballroom and multiple meeting rooms (8,000+ sq ft). | Conference center with ~3,800 sq ft and 2 meeting rooms. |
| Known for | Historic 1925 hotel, Salem Common location, wedding ballroom and local restaurants. | Waterfront location, marina/dock, indoor pool and central harbor access. |
Hawthorne sits beside Salem Common and is within easy walking distance of the Salem Witch Museum and Peabody Essex Museum.
Pick Hawthorne for the historic Common-front location and quick museum access.
Salem Waterfront is located on Derby Street with a dock, marina access and a short walk to central attractions.
Pick Salem Waterfront if you want waterfront views and immediate harbor access while remaining close to downtown.
Hawthorne offers 93 historically styled rooms and a handful of suites across its 1925 building.
Choose Hawthorne for characterful rooms and historic details close to Salem Common.
Salem Waterfront has 87 guestrooms in a modern, harbor-oriented property with a range of standard, superior and suite options.
Choose Salem Waterfront for modern rooms with in‑room conveniences and suite options for longer stays or families.
Hawthorne runs two in-house venues with a traditional, local-food focus and evening entertainment on select nights.
Hawthorne suits guests who want hotel-run dining with a historical/downtown atmosphere.
Salem Waterfront centers dining around Mainstay Social and limited room service hours.
Salem Waterfront works well if you prefer a single on-site restaurant and easy access to harbor-side dining nearby.
Hawthorne does not have an on-site swimming pool; waterfront/beach access requires a short trip.
If a pool is important, Hawthorne is not the choice — consider nearby beaches or fitness alternatives.
Salem Waterfront includes an indoor pool and direct marina/walkway-to-water access.
Salem Waterfront is the clear pick for travelers who want an indoor pool and direct harbor access.
Hawthorne offers event spaces and evening dining with occasional live music; wellness is limited but supported locally.
Choose Hawthorne for wedding/event needs and nightlife tied to its restaurants and bars.
Salem Waterfront supports meetings and medium-sized events with conference space and on-site banquet facilities.
Salem Waterfront fits groups who want waterfront meeting space and straightforward amenities for events.

Hawthorne — historic 1925 building beside Salem Common with on-site restaurants and period public rooms.

Salem Waterfront — dock, marina and walkway-to-water put you right on the harbor.

Hawthorne — large Grand Ballroom and multiple historic event spaces for weddings and larger meetings.

Salem Waterfront — indoor pool and suite options with refrigerators/microwaves for families.
Hawthorne Hotel — it sits beside Salem Common and is a very short walk to the Salem Witch Museum and Peabody Essex Museum.
Salem Waterfront Hotel & Suites has an indoor pool; Hawthorne does not have an on-site swimming pool.
Hawthorne Hotel — it offers more and larger event spaces, including the Grand Ballroom and multiple meeting rooms totaling over 8,000 sq ft.
Neither property guarantees breakfast included in the room rate; Hawthorne offers à la carte breakfast at Nathaniel's and Salem Waterfront lists cooked-to-order breakfast for a surcharge.
Explore how Hawthorne Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·