
Hawthorne Hotel
Best for walking Salem’s historic sites, small‑town charm, and family or pet-friendly stays.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hawthorne Hotel is a 1925 historic, 93-room hotel beside Salem Common, good for history-minded families, couples, and pet owners. The Liberty, a Marriott Luxury Collection Hotel, Boston is a five-star luxury property in a converted historic jail in Boston’s West End — read this if you want iconic design and a centrally located Boston base.
Updated · about 16 miles (≈26 km) apart

Best for walking Salem’s historic sites, small‑town charm, and family or pet-friendly stays.

Best for luxury design, central Boston access, and Marriott Luxury Collection service and branding.
When Hawthorne Hotel wins: choose Hawthorne if you want a compact, historic property steps from Salem Common and the Witch Museum, with an intimate ballroom and pet-friendly rooms — ideal for local sightseeing, weddings, and families.
When The Liberty wins: choose The Liberty if you want a high-end, design-forward stay inside a converted jail in central Boston with more restaurants, bars, meeting space, and stronger brand recognition for business or city breaks.
Bottom line: pick Hawthorne for a historic Salem experience and family/pet convenience; pick The Liberty for downtown Boston luxury, distinctive architecture, and a larger set of food, bar, and meeting amenities.
| Category | Hawthorne Hotel | The Liberty, a Marriott Luxury Collection Hotel, Boston |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, intimate, community-minded | Iconic, luxury, design-forward |
| Location | Beside Salem Common; steps to Salem Witch Museum and Peabody Essex Museum | Boston (West End) near Charles River Esplanade, TD Garden, and Boston Common |
| Size | 93 guestrooms and suites | 298 guestrooms |
| Age / building | Opened 1925; Federal-style historic hotel | Converted historic jail building (reimagined as a Luxury Collection hotel) |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | 2 in-house venues (Nathaniel's; The Tavern) with breakfast, lunch, dinner, and bar | 2 restaurants and 4 bars/lounges (room service limited hours; to-go breakfasts available for a fee) |
| Spa & wellness | Spa room with two massage tables (limited); small fitness room and complimentary nearby gym access reported | Fitness facilities on site; health/beauty spa listed as nearby rather than a named on-site spa |
| Known for | Historic charm, weddings and event spaces (Grand Ballroom, Sophia’s), pet-friendly policies | Distinctive jail-to-hotel conversion, Marriott Luxury Collection branding, central Boston location |
| Accessibility & business | Meeting and event space (over 8,000 sq ft); free parking; free Wi‑Fi | Conference space and meeting rooms; business center; extensive accessibility features and multilingual staff |
| Family & pets | Family-friendly; pet rooms on 6th floor with fee and pet perks | Adults-only: Not published; property allows families (not adults-only) |
Hawthorne Hotel sits beside Salem Common and is a short walk to Salem’s top historic attractions.
Pick Hawthorne to stay in the middle of Salem’s historic district and be within walking distance of the town’s main sights.
The Liberty is in Boston’s West End near Charles Street and the Charles River Esplanade.
Choose The Liberty for a central Boston base with strong walkability to downtown attractions.
Hawthorne Hotel offers 93 rooms and suites with historic character and several named room types.
Expect smaller, characterful rooms suited to travelers who value location and history over modern luxury trappings.
The Liberty has a wide selection of rooms (298 total) from Superior to Grand Rooms and multiple suites.
The Liberty offers more room types and larger inventory, better for travelers who want choice and upscale room amenities.
Hawthorne provides two on-site dining venues with local character.
Hawthorne’s dining is intimate and locally focused — good for relaxed meals and a historic atmosphere.
The Liberty lists 2 restaurants and 4 bars/lounges, plus limited room service and paid to-go breakfasts.
The Liberty gives a larger, city-scale dining and nightlife footprint for guests wanting more onsite variety.
Hawthorne’s notable selling point is its event and wedding facilities in a historic setting.
If you’re planning a historic Salem wedding or a mid-size meeting, Hawthorne’s event spaces are a major draw.
The Liberty also supports meetings and events with conference space and meeting rooms.
The Liberty is a better fit for larger city conferences or brand‑level event expectations in Boston.
Hawthorne offers modest on-site wellness and a relaxed evening scene.
Hawthorne covers basics for fitness and low-key evenings; it’s not a nightlife or full-spa destination.
The Liberty provides fitness facilities and on-site nightlife options.
The Liberty suits travelers who want more evening options and an on-site gym; for treatments, guests may need a nearby spa.

Hawthorne Hotel — steps from Salem Common, the Witch Museum, and the Peabody Essex Museum.

The Liberty — five-star Marriott Luxury Collection in a converted jail, near Boston Common and the Charles River.

Hawthorne Hotel — multiple historic event spaces including a Palladian-windowed Grand Ballroom.

The Liberty — multiple bars/lounges and city-scale dining options, plus a nightclub on site.
Hawthorne Hotel — it’s explicitly family-friendly, has kid-friendly menu options at The Tavern, and is within walking distance of Salem attractions.
The Liberty — it’s in central Boston near the Charles River Esplanade, Boston Common, and public transit for city sightseeing.
Hawthorne Hotel does not have an on-site swimming pool; The Liberty’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Hawthorne Hotel welcomes up to two pets per room (designated rooms on the 6th floor) for a fee. The Liberty’s supplier listing shows pets are allowed in specific rooms (fees apply) — contact the property for details.
Explore how Hawthorne Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·