Dining at the Hawthorne Hotel: Nathaniel’s and The Tavern explained

Nathaniel’s is the Hawthorne Hotel’s main restaurant serving cooked-to-order breakfast daily and a limited dinner service with live music on select evenings; The Tavern is the hotel’s all-day, fireside pub serving burgers, sandwiches, salads, cocktails and rotating local drafts. Both are on-site at 18 Washington Square West and accept reservations (The Tavern pauses reservations in October).
In this guide
Overview: two distinct dining experiences
Nathaniel’s and The Tavern are the Hawthorne Hotel’s two on-site restaurants, each aimed at different parts of the day and different moods. Nathaniel’s operates as the hotel’s breakfast restaurant and transforms into an evening lounge on weekend dinner nights with live music.
The Tavern is a casual, pub-style restaurant and bar located off the lobby that serves lunch and dinner daily, with a wood-burning fireplace, oak-paneled walls, and views of Salem Common.
photo":52} ,{
h2":"Nathaniel’s at a glance","paragraphs":["What to expect: Nathaniel’s offers contemporary American breakfast items each morning and a limited dinner program on specific evenings (live music typically begins in the evening on dinner nights).","Hours and service: breakfast is served daily (hotel pages list morning hours around 7:30 a.m.–11:00 a.m., with slightly different published weekend times); dinner service is offered on select days with live entertainment beginning around 6:00 p.m.","Practical notes: breakfast is available à la carte (not included in standard room rates); Nathaniel’s accepts major credit cards including American Express, Discover, Mastercard and Visa."
bullets":["Breakfast daily: cooked-to-order morning menu","Evening dining: limited nights with live piano/acoustic music","Reservations: accepted via OpenTable or by phone","Payment: AMEX, Discover, Mastercard, Visa accepted"],
| Service | Typical Hours | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Breakfast | Morning (hotel lists around 7:30–11:00 a.m.) | À la carte; not included with room |
| Dinner | Select evenings (hotel lists Thu–Sat or Fri–Sun depending on source) | Live music; lounge-like evening vibe |
| Reservations | Yes | Use OpenTable or call the hotel |

The Tavern: pub fare, cocktails and Salem Common views
The Tavern (sometimes called Tavern on the Green in listings) is the hotel’s casual bar and restaurant off the lobby. It serves an all-day menu of burgers, sandwiches, salads, comfort dishes and kid-friendly options alongside a full bar and rotating local drafts.
Ambiance and layout: The Tavern features oak-paneled walls, wing-backed chairs and a real wood-burning fireplace, with tables facing Salem Common for outdoor views when available. The bar remains open later than the kitchen on many nights.
Practical tips: The Tavern accepts reservations for most of the year, but the hotel and local tourism sites note that reservations are not accepted during October because of heavy seasonal demand.
bullets":["Hours: Lunch & Dinner daily (hotel lists roughly 11:00 a.m.–10:00 p.m.), bar open later","Menu: burgers, salads, sandwiches, vegan and gluten-free options listed by the hotel","Bar: full bar with rotating local draft beers","Reservations: generally accepted except during October"],
photo":66},{
| When to go | Why choose it |
|---|---|
| Breakfast at Nathaniel’s | Quick cooked-to-order meals and full morning menu |
| Lunch or casual dinner at The Tavern | Casual menu, fireside seating, full bar |
| Evening at Nathaniel’s | Live music and a quieter lounge-style meal |
Choosing between Nathaniel’s and The Tavern
Pick Nathaniel’s for a traditional sit-down breakfast or a quieter evening with live acoustic music on dinner nights; it shifts from daytime restaurant to lounge-like evening service. Choose The Tavern for a casual lunch, relaxed dinner, or drinks beside a fireplace and for a broader bar selection and rotating local drafts.
If you’re traveling with kids or need flexible, all-day food, The Tavern’s all-day menu includes kid options and several items marked for gluten-free or vegan diners. If you have limited time in the morning, Nathaniel’s is the place for a cooked-to-order breakfast.
When the hotel is busy (especially in October), The Tavern can fill quickly and the hotel notes reservations aren’t accepted in October—plan accordingly or arrive early.
bullets":["Family meals: The Tavern is more kid-oriented and open all day","Morning-only meals: Nathaniel’s is focused on breakfast service","Evenings: Nathaniel’s offers live music on certain nights; The Tavern provides bar seating and later hours"] ,
photo":-1},{
| Best for | Good to know |
|---|---|
| Solo coffee or lobby tea | Complimentary coffee and tea are available in the lobby throughout the day |
| Group brunch or hotel events | Nathaniel’s does a Sunday Jazz Brunch (per some listings) |
| Cocktails and local beer | Choose The Tavern for rotating drafts and an oak-paneled bar |
Dining and events: private functions and wedding meals
Both dining spaces at the hotel are used for private events. Nathaniel’s and some smaller rooms (like the Pickman Room) are often used for intimate rehearsal dinners, showers, and private meals, while larger receptions typically use the Grand Ballroom or Sophia’s.
The hotel’s wedding and events pages describe multi-room packages that include cocktail receptions, plated dinners and open-bar options; event details and menu selections are handled through the hotel’s event team.
If you’re booking a group meal, tell the hotel which event space you prefer and ask about menu options, service charges, and whether the Tavern or Nathaniel’s will be available to the public during your event.
bullets":["Small private dinners: Nathaniel’s or Pickman Room can be arranged","Larger receptions: Grand Ballroom handles banquet events","Event planning: contact the hotel’s sales or events team for menus and pricing details"] ,
photo":-1} ,{
| Event space | Typical use | Capacity examples |
|---|---|---|
| Pickman Room | Intimate dinners/meeting | ~20–30 reception |
| Nathaniel’s/Smaller rooms | Private meals and showers | Varies by set-up |
| Grand Ballroom | Large receptions/banquets | Ballroom capacities listed by hotel |


